Politics

Confidential Blackwater report reveals unprovoked shooting
This story has mostly positive ratings. 144 votes / 1 sink

Confidential Blackwater report reveals unprovoked shooting

Politics – An extensive evidence file assembled by the Iraqi National Police after the controversial Blackwater shooting suggests that the private contractors opened fire unprovoked from the ground and the sky.

Tags: Blackwater, Iraq, Report

Report

Filter Comments ›
1 - 50 of 119 Comments by 46 members  RSS Feed for comments

1 2 3 > »

Add Comment
avatar
Reply

This entire corporation of monstrous thugs needs to be disarmed and disbanded, and a great many of them arrested, tried and convicted. What an absolutely evil creation.

avatar
Reply

then who will protect the contractors in Iraq?

avatar
Reply

You and all the rest of you war-mongers. You want the war. Send yourselves and your families over there. Time to walk the talk.

avatar
Reply

We shouldn't have been there to begin with. have 180,000 contractors there in no bid patronage contracts. This is what this debacle is all about. Wake up!! If you want the troops protected you and your kind should be there. Put your money where your mouth is!! Put the draft on the warmonging, Bush supporters

avatar
Reply

I have advocated this since they started talking about the draft. All that voted for Bush will be put in the draft. No one else, no Libs, No Libertarians, No green party, no commies, no socialists. Just Neocons. You go fight for your heroes war of aggression.

avatar
Reply

Why not look who voted for war from the body who authroizes it?

Right, because one has to admit that it is a bipartisan effort when we tally Congressional votes.

avatar
Reply

If we want to be in so many hostile places then the answer is not no-bid contracts.

The proper answer is to take all those funds being spend on Blackwater and others of their ilk and put that into Military Pay budgets.

You want war then pay for it by providing enough pay to entice the needed people to volunteer for the military.

What is entirely inappropriate is sending in our soliders ill equiped, without proper rest between multiple tours, and among the worst paid government employees while we pay contractors higher than most civilian jobs to do what should be done by the military.

How many more would volunteer with better pay, better, equipment, proper rest, and proper care if they come home injured?

avatar
Reply

Just think about that. The republicons do not support our troops, but they do support a government funded private army. Hmmm.

avatar
Reply

Read Naomi Wolf's "The End of America." There's an illuminating section on private armies, and their place in the classic 'fascist shift.'

avatar
Reply

--who will protect the contractors in Iraq?

Reinstate the draft. But in the first lottery we must put all the congress's, and the President's children in first.

avatar
Reply

"then who will protect the contractors in Iraq?"

Who cares, not me, they don't belong there in the first place.

avatar
Reply

It seems you're spouting the GOP line Anyone But Me. But then again Petraeus just got done saying howmuch better it is and you;re saying they still need protection?

avatar
Reply

We could get more honest, cost-effective, and HONORABLE security from Chinese or Russian firms.

avatar
Reply

My first reaction to such articles used to always be, "let's just wait till the investigation is complete." Sadly, now all I am expecting is a large serving of whitewash. Every time Bush investigates Bush, he finds no wrongdoing whatsoever.

avatar
Reply

"Every time Bush investigates Bush, he finds no wrongdoing whatsoever.z"

I read the article, and it said nothing of Bush. Obviously, you have your liberal blinders on yet again (no surprise there).

If any politician is involved, it most likely would be Dem. Sen. Dianne Feinstein and her crooked hubby - or did you conveniently forget it was her and her hubby caught rigging military contracts for personal profit and not Bush?

avatar
Reply

Talk about blinders. The Blackwater shooting is all the Feinstein's fault. Yeah sure. Next...

avatar
Reply

Sorry senators do not I repead and shout DO NOT make military contracts.

Military contracts are made and executed by the Department of Defense which if you need a government lesson is part of the Executive (administration) not the legistlative (congress) branch of government.

The politicians in charge of military contracts go up the line ending at the top with the Secretary of Defense and the President/Vice President all of whom I am sure unlike your jaded view would not do anything to help Feinstein or and other democratic congress person.

avatar
Reply

There's only one name used to authorize US troops and contractors in Iraq, you and I both know it is George W Bush.

avatar
Reply

Why would we find Dems even involved in the no-bid contracts of Blackwater?

We ALL know about the contributions of Eric Prince to the Reproblican party. His sister was even the bigwig Reproblican in Michigan. Even a worse third-degree association, his sister is married to the president of Amway.

libsRfunny like booksRfunny... especially when you can't even read. Duhhh*Hick*!

avatar
Reply

Sounds like genocide and war crimes to me.

avatar
Reply

Oh, sorry, er, I mean, America #1, God bless America and no one else, support the troops!

avatar
Reply

Yeah you're right, support the troops not these thugs.

avatar
Reply

Armchair quarterbacks complaining. Everybody glossed over the fact that there were bullet holes in a Blackwater car. These people obviously don't have the training of our soldiers but the people labeling "evil", "genocide", etc. are not thinking. Unless you have received the training that our soldiers have then when in fear of your life there is a tendency to shoot first and ask questions later when fired upon. All it took was one person firing a few rounds at them to start this mess.

What would you people do if you had a gun and someone started shooting at you.

avatar
Reply

So why are the soldiers there? Please, tell us.

avatar
Reply

While you're at it tell us who's army these people are from.

avatar
Reply

Did you even bother to read the article?

-"What would you people do if you had a gun and someone started shooting at you"-

Nowhere in the report is there any evidence that anyone instigated this by starting a shooting with the Blackwater contingent. Quite the contrary.

You are deliberately attempting to falsify information to support the murder of innocent civilians.

avatar
Reply

So you skipped over this part?

"Still images provided to the network show a Blackwater vehicle pocked with five bullet marks."

avatar
Reply

My guess is that in a shootout...cars get holes in them.

Particularly when coming from helicopters.

avatar
Reply

"Did you even bother to read the article?"

Obviously you didn't.

"Nowhere in the report is there any evidence that anyone instigated this by starting a shooting with the Blackwater contingent. Quite the contrary."

I provide proof from the article but this is your response?

So who is "deliberately attempting to falsify information"?

avatar
Reply

So bullet holes prove that someone ELSE started this battle?

How about the several other cars that were riddled with bullet holes and burned as a result of the attack?

Is that proof that Blackwater started it?

During gunfights bullet holes happen.

Or are you implying that because the car was hit with bullets, regardless of how the fight was instigated, the Iraqis shouldnt shoot back?

I have never participated in nor lived through a civil war, but my guess is that I would carry a weapon and shoot back at the people who were shooting at me.

Your 'proof' is speculative at best.

avatar
Reply

I didn't say it was absolute proof. I just countered your argument

"Nowhere in the report is there any evidence that anyone instigated this by starting a shooting with the Blackwater contingent. Quite the contrary."

avatar
Reply

They produced a vehicle with five bullet mark on it that mean nothing because there is ZERO proof it is the original vehicle from the massacre. They should hall in Blackwaters top executives and hold them on murder charges until they get full cooperation and the people responsible, then a public trial and what ever the local court hand down for sentence.

avatar
Reply

Show me some proof that the bullet holes in the Blackwater cars were made before the Blackwater guards started shooting and prove that the holes were not from their own helicopters or guns.

avatar
Reply

If these Blackwater jackboots prance around the countryside the way they've been shown to do, you could easily conclude that they and their vehicles are bullet MAGNETS.

avatar
Reply

Not onlyis it speculative but there is nothing in the article that says Blackwater in the process of shooting anything that was moving was firing all over the place couldn't have made those holes. THOSE holes could have been the result of Blackwater firing. But of course the right wing stops short of logically looking at things especially when it doesn't support their fantasies of reality. Kinda like the Limpaw thing. Dont believe what you hear on the radio believe this several days later.

avatar
Reply

And those bullets were from insurgents guns? Oh yeah wait the article doesnt mention that I guess you must have just figured that right? Despite the fact BlackWater was firing from the sky and the ground.

avatar
Reply

"Unless you have received the training that our soldiers have then when in fear of your life there is a tendency to shoot first and ask questions later when fired upon."

That would be a valid argument except for the fact most are ex military and have had the very training you spoke of, many of the elite special forces are among Blackwater personal.

avatar
Reply

Yes most of them are ex-military, many having left the military because they could make more money serving as mercenaries for Blackwater. This is why privatizing the war is such a problem. We pay extra just so Blackwater can make 100s of millions of dollars performing tasks that should be for the army.

avatar
Reply

We might start an insurgency and defend our country.

avatar
Reply

Note the testimony from Iraqi police officers - there is no evidence that the Blackwater goons were actually shot at.

avatar
Reply

Blackwater is nothing but a bunch of 'trigger-happy' idiots playing 'cowboys & indians'. Blackwater ought to be put on trial in the Hague by the World Court.

One must ask: what in the world did the Iraqi citizens do to America to deserve such vicious & criminal attacks? Oh, I forgot, WMD's & terrorism!?

avatar
Reply

You forgot to mention all of the co conspirators of the war crimes. Powell, Bush, Rove, Cheney, Rummy, Rice, and all of the other traitors to this country who had anything to do with Vietraq.

avatar
Reply

Endo,

Blackwater's people DO have the training of soldiers. They are mercenaries.

avatar
Reply

Most of them are former marines.

avatar
Reply

Not true, most are special ops people.

And if I wanted to hire someone to protect my butt in Iraq. I'd hire these guys.

avatar
Reply

Regardless, it's not fair to defend them by claiming they have insufficient training.

avatar
Reply

Who did that?

avatar
Reply

"These people obviously don't have the training of our soldiers ..." - Endoscopy

avatar
Reply

They also don't have accountability by law. An NPR story within the hour states that some of those mercenaries may face criminal charges.

How? They are not accountable to Iraq or US military law! As I stated above, read N. Wolf's "The End of America." It spells out plainly where all this is leading.

avatar
Reply

Read:

Blackwater: The Rise of the World's Most Powerful Mercenary Army by Jeremy Scahill.

Probably a bit slanted for your taste, but if you can get past that, it is a well researched and documented account of how they grew to their current stature, WHO they are and how they operate.

1 2 3 > »

Add Comment

You must log in first to post a comment. Secure Signin

Not a member? Sign-up today!


Who voted on this story?

View all (133) »

Who sunk this story?

Channels
AnchorsArt & DesignAutos
BooksCareers & JobsCelebrities
Do No EvilDo-It-YourselfFamily
FoodGadgets & TechGay & Lesbian
Health & FitnessHumorLove & Personals
MenMoneyMovies
MusicNewsPets
PoliticsPopular VideosReal Estate
ReligionScienceShopping
SportsTelevisionTravel
VideoVideo GamesWomen