Got feedback on the new design? We're Listening! Send us Feedback

Confirmed: Barack Obama Practiced Islam »

Posted by: RedRiverJ 7 months, 2 weeks ago

96 Comments Report this Story

8.4

Scale of 1 to 10

Read: 33

Propped: 45

Comments: 96

Click Prop It to Raise Score
Prop it

In a recent analysis, "Was Barack Obama a Muslim?" I surveyed available evidence and found it suggests "Obama was born a Muslim to a non-practicing Muslim father and for some years had a reasonably Muslim upbringing under the auspices of his Indonesian step-father." In response, David Brock's organization, Media Matters for Amer

Read Full Story at frontpagemagazine.com

Join the Discussion

+ Add Comment
Comments So Far: 96
  • 0%
    RedRiverJ7 months, 2 weeks ago

    From the article:

    Because Soetoro was a Muslim, Obama was listed as a Muslim, she said. In their first neighborhood, Obama occasionally followed his stepfather to the mosque for Friday prayers, a few neighbors said.

    Interesting Obama has tried to keep this quiet. I would think he would being a Muslim would be part of his heritage something that would make him proud??

    Reply

    10 Replies

  • 0%
    lvrofwolves7 months, 2 weeks ago

    JohnQ-I felt almost exactly as you described, but I'm not going to be calling people names. I remember very clearly what I was taught and what I did, likes and dislikes.

    And regardless of if I would have rather been outside playing or not, what my family practiced did have some impact on my life even if later I chose a different path. It becomes part of your make-up. I'm not of any religious affiliation, but I'd never become Muslim, it's totally opposite of my upbringing, and I'm not saying being Muslim is bad, just as I wouldn't say being Christian is good. I have no real experiance of living as a Muslim.

    Reply

    2 Replies

    • 0%
      aniokly7 months, 2 weeks ago

      It might not matter to some people that he is a former Muslim, but it will matter to enough people to keep him out of the oval office. It will be interesting to see if he is a gracious loser, or if he will throw a hissy fit like Al Gore when he loses.

      .

      Reply

      1 Reply

  • 0%
    Amazing17 months, 2 weeks ago

    So freaking what! Any religion practiced with any kind of humility and reverence for the core teachings of that faith is a good thing. That he has been exposed to more than one religion is a good thing.

    He has probably hidden it because of the negative blowback he knows would come his way if the so-called Christians found out about it. They would be beating their bibles and screaming heresy. And why? Because in a nation where we are supposed to have absolute freedom of religion, these extremists do not really want anyone to have a belief that doesn't match theirs. These fundamentalists believe that it is their way of the highway.

    Reply

    4 Replies

    • 0%
      rockman0697 months, 2 weeks ago

      If you think it is just the fundamentalists saying so, then say it--all Christians are fundamentalists. There is a deep-rooted problem that many, MANY agnostics to atheists claim against the Christian, separation of church and state and all that.

      Now that we realize there is a possibility of a dormant Muslim occupying the most powerful position in the US as the commander-in-chief, suddenly religion is nothing.

      Who is talking out the side of their mouth now?

      Reply

      3 Replies

  • 0%
    not2needy7 months, 2 weeks ago

    Why is everyone looking for something to crucify Obama?

    The way his father/stepfather did, or what he did as a child, should have no bearing on his qualifications to be president.

    I knew this would start, people want to think they have enough class not to play the race card, so they will go back to his birth and play the Muslim card.

    I know several Muslims, and none of them are calling for my death or anyone else's.

    People need to get over this!

    Reply

    9 Replies

    • 0%
      ranchhand7 months, 2 weeks ago

      OK I'll bite. What race is he? Mother white and father black seems to me thats fifty-fifty so what he's all 100%human and that should be all that should concern you about his race.

      Reply

      3 Replies

    • 0%
      bill29367 months, 2 weeks ago

      So what are his qualifications to be President?

      Reply
    • 0%
      abntv7 months, 2 weeks ago

      The point that should be taken away from this is that Muslims believe..once a muslim always a muslim and many believe those that turn away from their religion must be put to death.

      Reply
      • 0%
        abntv7 months, 2 weeks ago

        I would question the ability of a person that has converted from muslim to chrisianity has the ability to deal with the radical parties involved in terrorism

        Reply

        1 Reply

      • 0%
        abntv7 months, 2 weeks ago

        I am not out to crucify anyone..I have nothing personal against Obama...I just question his ability to handle problems in the middle east..along with other issues.

        Reply

        8 Replies

      • 0%
        rockman0697 months, 2 weeks ago

        I think that Obama actually has a good platform, from what I have been hearing.

        That is not the problem. The fact that he covers up and hides under the guise of Christian, but finds a church that claims to preach the Bible but upholds the African traditions and mentality causes some concern about what other surprises are in store for the rest of us if he were elected. Some claim that he wouldn't have a chance had he publicly admitted to being Muslim.

        I wish he would have been forthright from the beginning, instead of this. It was even stated that the claims of his Muslim background was fabricated.

        Strange how that seems to be changing now...

        Reply
        • 0%
          RedRiverJ7 months, 2 weeks ago

          I wish he would have been forthright from the beginning, instead of this. It was even stated that the claims of his Muslim background was fabricated. I agree.

          Reply
          • 0%
            Redneck7 months, 2 weeks ago

            If Obama is a "non-practicing Muslim" there are several possible senarios to consider: 1) he is open to attack by all practicing Muslims as a heretic which could be attempts at assassination unless he renews his faith. 2) Muslims will reject dealing with him as a heretic. 3) He renews his allegiance and therefore his faith in that religion would require him to favor it or be branded heretic again.

            One must be sure of the tenets of faith of Islam. There is little wiggle room contrary to being a Christian. Their leaders demand absolute obedience and observance. They have a worldview which is contrary to Western culture and at least the "great Satan" as they call us.

            Now IF he is truly a convert from Islam to Christianity I say great. But then some of the points above still hold. I do not want a Muslim in the presidency since Islam by and large has declared war on US because to adhere to that religion one must hold the view of its leaders.

            Reply
            • 0%
              MeanMotherUSA7 months, 2 weeks ago

              1-7-08...

              REALLY WEIRD: Since He Admitted On Jay Leno T V Talk Show Past December 2008--Obamainia Is Blood Relative Of Dickh*ad Vice President Chenny!

              MeanMotherUSA

              Reply

              1 Reply

              • 0%
                RedRiverJ7 months, 2 weeks ago

                I had forgotten that one....about obama and cheney.

                Reply
              • 0%
                cowboygrandpa7 months, 2 weeks ago

                Well, all I can say is I don't know enough one way or another to make any intelligent choice. So I will refrain from saying anything bombastic or favoring him.

                I will do more research and learn where he stands. I don't favor him right now anyway. I'm leaning more towards Edwards as he seems to want to put a crimp in the corporate stampede. Just my opinion.

                Reply
                • 0%
                  Albmore7 months, 2 weeks ago

                  JohnQPublic is no different than the Neocons he writes about but for the other side. Are questions about his religion going to come up? Yes. Is it a factor? With 90% of the US claiming to belong to some religion, YES.

                  But this is just one of many questions he should and will be asked. Funny I did not see such a response from JOHNQ. when statements were raised on Huck's or Mitts religion.

                  People like JOHNQ that are die heart party fans will make America weaker. Ask every canidate every question you can. Get as many facts as you can. Then make your decission without bias. America survival depends upon it.

                  Reply

                  1 Reply

                  • 0%
                    MajJohn7 months, 2 weeks ago

                    I guess most of us are die hards except for the independents. So JQ is defending his turf. We all do it but most of us are no so bombastic. Religion, race, and sex will all be issues at one time or another in this 2008 race. This makes it one of the most interesting years in memory.

                    Reply
                  • 0%
                    getreal17 months, 2 weeks ago

                    Who all, does he plan to put in his cabinet if he becomes president?

                    Reply
                    • 0%
                      Albmore7 months, 2 weeks ago

                      Good question and who will be his vice? Now God forbid something would happen but if he wins his personal security will also be a question and who would take over if something happened.

                      The same would be with Hillary. Even though it is not a popular topic it is one that must be questioned.

                      Reply

                      1 Reply

                      • 0%
                        RedRiverJ7 months, 2 weeks ago

                        Senator Dick Durbin from Illinois might be a choice?

                        Reply
                      • 0%
                        endtyranny7 months, 2 weeks ago

                        We all know that Barack Obama is a Christian, but if he was taught about Islam as a child, all the better. The Middle East is going to be the center of attention for the next administration's foreign policy as it has been in this admin and we should be choosing leaders who understand it and it's followers.

                        Reply
                        • 0%
                          browneyedGAgirl7 months, 2 weeks ago

                          When people intelligent enough to take time to research the important political issues the candidates run their platform on, show up at the polls in numbers, quite possibly the election victors will actually be what this country needs in leadership and strength to get the US back on track. I am not naive enough to think that a person's religious preference doesn't make a difference, but be reminded that we do have a system of checks and balances in our country that disallow any one person or government branch from having too much power.

                          Reply

                          1 Reply

                          • 0%
                            Grrr7 months, 2 weeks ago

                            Well, we did have those checks and balances, once...

                            Reply
                          • 0%
                            browneyedGAgirl7 months, 2 weeks ago

                            I would also like to mention that the radical extremists of any religion are problematic, typically not the loyal followers who are true to their religion. We have had displays over and again of terroristic-type behavior from white US citizens who have killed innocent people in the name of their "religion." Any rites and rituals of religion that are in writing are always open to interpreta... and the Christian Bible is no exception. Sometimes you get out of it exactly what you want to get out of it...

                            Reply
                            • 0%
                              BSBowden7 months, 2 weeks ago

                              Why does this matter? The US President should honor the implicit tenets of the constitution and subsequent Supreme Court decisions which aver the SEPARATION OF CHURCH AND STATE in all government affairs. The US President could be Christian, Jewish, Muslim, Bhuddist, Taoist, Wiccan, or Atheist - because his faith should not bias him against his/her duties as president, should not bias him against others based on religion, nor inform his policy-making decisions.

                              What is far more important is - will a candidate's religious background (whatever that is) change, shape, or inform his decisions regarding US policy?!? The country is a NOT affiliated with any religion (there is no state religion and no one must be a member of any sect to be an American) and its policies should reflect that.

                              Let's be frightened by folks who stand up and proudly say "I believe in a 'Chocolate Donut' and that belief will inform the domestic and foreign agenda of my administration."

                              Reply

                              1 Reply

                              • 0%
                                RedRiverJ7 months ago

                                They all want separation of Church and State, but they all appear during their campaigns at Church to give speeches.............. They separate when it benefits them and when it is politically correct. All of them, Obama no exception.

                                Reply
                              • 0%
                                Bkumm7 months, 2 weeks ago

                                And so it continues. First it was the use of his middle name (Hussein, which means beautiful or doer of good deeds in Arabic), now it's that he was raised a Muslim.

                                It's nice to see that America has grown up. Oh, wait...

                                Reply
                                • 0%
                                  ynotb4real7 months, 2 weeks ago

                                  I like the "Duh"-nut party let put thier candiate in office!

                                  Reply
                                  • 0%
                                    aniokly7 months, 2 weeks ago

                                    No one is saying Barak Hussein Obama is a Muslim today. We are saying he is a former Muslim who, for some reason, refuses to acknowledge his Muslim background. Why? Because he knows once he does we will know he lied all this time, and we will wonder what else he is lying about.

                                    Reply
                                    • 0%
                                      mr2047 months, 2 weeks ago

                                      Hey.

                                      I'm a neoclown (conservative thank you), and all of my Persian and Arab Muslim friends and business associates are conservatives too. No one I know of has any problem with any public figure who is (or was) Muslim. If no one asks, no one is lying. I think Obama is a good guy, he's good for the presidential race and the country. I'm just not going to vote for him this time around.

                                      Besides, I thought this was old news.

                                      Reply
                                      • 0%
                                        aniokly7 months, 2 weeks ago

                                        Well. your Checks, and balances are not working on President Bush. The Democrats are pretty much giving him what ever he wants.

                                        Reply
                                        • 0%
                                          MonkeyBiz7 months, 2 weeks ago

                                          This whole "Obama is a Muslim" thing has been debunked and debunked again and again, yet some will not give up spreading lies and innuendo.

                                          The author of the hit piece claims that because someone states that Obama was not a "regular" mosque attending muslim, then ergo, he must be an "irregular" mosque attending muslim and hence a muslim beyond doubt. If you think this makes sense, you need a short course in logic.

                                          Here's the argument put another way. Fact: George Bush is not a regular mosque attending muslim, hence he must be an irregular mosque attending muslim, and thus George Bush is a MUSLIM. He may claim otherwise, but there is the proof!

                                          OMG!!!

                                          Here's another one. Fact: "Dead eye" Dick Cheney is not a "regular" cross dressing pervert, hence he must be an irregular cross dressing pervert, thus Cheney is a cross dressing pervert.

                                          Isn't this fun? If you really get the hang of it, you too can become as influential as Karl Rove!

                                          Reply

                                          1 Reply

                                          • 0%
                                            MajJohn7 months, 2 weeks ago

                                            Gee, Chaney a pervert?. I didn't know. This is fun!

                                            Reply
                                          • 0%
                                            bugluver7 months, 2 weeks ago

                                            I saw the show they did on him I think last summer on the Bio channel. I wish I could remember his exact quote it was something to the effect that he was doing a lot of Grassroots campaign and it seamed to be a good idea to belong to a church. Did anyone else see that? Not much conviction either way.

                                            Reply
                                            • 0%
                                              aniokly7 months, 2 weeks ago

                                              You don't get it. No one cares if he is a former Muslim, we are just curious about why he finds it necessary to pretend he he wasn't a Muslim. All he has to do is clear it up. He, not his wife, his friends, his Granny, Him.

                                              Reply

                                              3 Replies

                                              • 0%
                                                MonkeyBiz7 months, 2 weeks ago

                                                YOU don't get it. He is not a Muslim and he is not a former Muslim. He is a Christian that belongs to an African-American church.

                                                Reading your previous posts, the African-American part is your problem with him.

                                                Reply

                                                1 Reply

                                              • 0%
                                                Will13137 months, 1 week ago

                                                when you did things because your parents REQUESTED that you do them.. before you are old enough to make decisions on your own.. DOES NOT DEFINE ANY ADULT....YOU OR ANYONE ELSE....

                                                Reply
                                              • 0%
                                                aniokly7 months, 2 weeks ago

                                                It is a proven fact he attended a Private Catholic school for third, and forth grade in Indonesia, and was listed as a Muslim. So he attended prayers at a nearby by mosque. He also attended Muslim prayers with his step father at the same Mosque. You cannot alter those facts. That has never been debunked. I don't care what color the people are in his chosen Church. I do care that they are so anti-white as to not even allow white people in attendence. What is up with that? He wants to be President to all of us, not just the black ones. Or does he?

                                                Reply

                                                1 Reply

                                                • 0%
                                                  Will13137 months, 1 week ago

                                                  So he attended prayers at a nearby by mosque. He also attended Muslim prayers with his step father at the same Mosque.

                                                  ---

                                                  at that age.. you pretty much do what your parents TELL YOU TO DO.....

                                                  ------

                                                  I attended church at that age... .. and that's the LAST place you'd find me today..

                                                  NEXT NON ISSUE PLEASE....

                                                  Reply
                                                Next 25 comments

                                                You must be signed in to post a comment. Sign in »

                                                Submitted By:
                                                RedRiverJ

                                                Don't like many politicians. Strong feelings on needing a border fence, tighter security measures at all points of entry. Will discuss issues, will not ...

                                                Also submitted:

                                                Related Articles:

                                                Why not submit a story?

                                                Also Propping This Article

                                                view all »

                                                Groups Watching This

                                                No groups are watching this story. Why not share it with your group?

                                                Advertisement