Politics

Tapes destroyed over CIA's objections
This story has mostly positive ratings. 111 votes / 2 sinks

Tapes destroyed over CIA's objections

Politics – The CIA official who gave the command to destroy interrogation videotapes apparently acted against the direction of his superiors, the top Republican House Intelligence Committee member said Wednesday.

Tags: Tapes, Destroyed, CIAS, Objections

Report

Filter Comments ›
1 - 50 of 84 Comments by 27 members  RSS Feed for comments

1 2 > »

Add Comment
avatar
Reply

Well Mr. Rodriguez, you have a tough choice here: You can take the fall and be rewarded later, or you can refuse to play and cut your career short.

avatar
Reply

"Now, I ask you: Deal, or no deal?"

avatar
Reply

I don't know but to me this is the REPUGS excuse for everything, if these agencies cant keep their own in line should we worry about them keeping others in line. This is a flat out lie and i am sick and tired of the right doing this. We need to rid ourselves of them!

avatar
Reply

I think the death penalty would be too kind of a punishment for this scum. These kind of Neo-con bums are going to ruin the United States.

The history of the CIA is the history of horror and cruelty through out the world.

They are the henchman for our corporately controlled government.

avatar
Reply

"the death penalty"

You must be crazy. What was his great "crime"? Totally blown out of proportion.

avatar
Reply

"What was his great "crime""

Ordering the destruction of evidence of crimes against humanity, protecting a bunch of low life criminals going right up to the Whitehouse. His actions make him just as guilty as those ordering and committing the crime.

avatar
Reply

"crimes against humanity"

Are you serious? Waterboarding are crimes against humanity? Dude you'd better take a long look around before you make that statement.

avatar
Reply

Sorry for the positive vote, hit the wrong button. Water boarding is a crime in the US as well as according to the UDHR which the US helped draw and sign. Elonore Roosevelt chaired the comity which drew it up so I guarantee you the US government knows it and that they broke the law. Americans have been charged and found guilty of it under American law so it's on the books and both Germen and Japanese soldiers were convicted of it after ww2, so it's on record as being a war crime. Do you need with the big words or what?

avatar
Reply

"Do you need with the big words or what?"

Not sure what you meant by this but seems you've been hanging with Daylight to much.

You've been proven wrong so many times that until I see an example I'll assume your spewing nonsense, AGAIN.

avatar
Reply

People have chosen not to believe me but thats a far step from being proven wrong. My comment referred to you not understanding laws already written, most people can simply read them and them know whats against the law.

avatar
Reply

I just read UDHR. Absolutely no reference to water boarding. None. Zip. Nada.

avatar
Reply

Waterboarding is a new name and method of water torture. The Japanese used the drip method and it was called torture.

avatar
Reply

Yes and they were convicted of war crimes and crimes against humanity for doing it.

avatar
Reply

"Article 5

No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment."

Now as the above states torture and numerous people have been convicted under this and American law for using water boarding and other water torture methods. I really do think you need help reading, I have a 10 year old niece who could help you if you like.

avatar
Reply

sorry crghss, but it took me less than 5 seconds to Google this with hundreds of other links to check out. I Googled water torture in WWII. Here is the link:

http://laurencejarvikonline.blogspot.com/2007/1...

avatar
Reply

The thing is People died because of these guys. If you must ask about their crime!

avatar
Reply

crghss ~

Maybe you don't remember, but "I was just following orders",

didn't cut it with the global community when the Germans

said it. That was when the United States was still proud to

be part of a global community that found torture abhorent.

My, how times change!

avatar
Reply

Your comparing waterboarding to the Holocaust? A little bit different don't you think? How many people died from the water boarding? How many died from the Holocaust?

avatar
Reply

crghss ~

As I recall, the Holocaust involved extermination AND

lots and lots of torture too - you know like filth and

starvation and stress-positions and beatings and forced

separation of parents and children and so much more.

The SS was fascinated with hypothermia too - and not

every victim died - but that counts too doesn't it?

Even if you took away the crematoriums and the gas chambers

- I don't think there was anything to reccommend about life

in the camps. Quality of life matters - treatment of human

beings matters - doesn't it?

P.S. Once again, you ONLY reference waterboarding!

We are using all manner of torture.

avatar
Reply

"We are using all manner of torture."

I haven't seen this. Care to show me?

avatar
Reply

Can't show you, remember they already destroyed the tapes.

avatar
Reply

Here is two for starters. It took 15 seconds to find, load and bring them to this sight. I Googled US torture.

http://www.forbes.com/work/feeds/afx/2005/06/24...

http://www.guardian.co.uk/usa/story/0,12271,166...

avatar
Reply

ML2007 ~

Thank you so much for the link to the Guardian article.

I was taking The Nation in 2005 - don't know how I missed it!

Outstanding article though - many thanks.

avatar
Reply

Going to, It's going to take hard work to fix what they have broken...and it seems they are hell bent on leaving a mess behind in order to say see they cant fix the country!

avatar
Reply

Boy, if this doesn't look like a CLASSIC case of "who's going to take the fall" I don't know what does. This story stinks so bad I can smell the chife all the way out here in Illinois.

avatar
Reply

I think the reason the tapes where destroyed was with the reputation this administration has for prosecuting those who carried out their orders the agents in the tapes wanted them gone before they where hung out to dry like the soldiers at Abu Garaib.

avatar
Reply

His career is pretty much over. What reward? He only has retirement left.

avatar
Reply

I think the reward is possibly pointing to any career choices after taking the fall. Will there be more opportunity and compensation rewarding loyalty? That is considering an assumption that the citizens of this country are not getting the full story. There is some precedence for such things.

avatar
Reply

The joke in all this, if you are trying not to cry, is that we have somehow elected or let the elected appoint the worse of American from top to bottom into every power position of our government even the Supreme Courts. It will take an entire generation to recover from what they have done.

We would have been better off opening up a prison and letting the inmates run the country.

My god they are the worse of what we have to offer. And the Media they should all be suspended from practicing their work. The last good News man was Anderson Cooper and they found a way to keep his mouth shut. We are in soo much trouble as a nation i hope god keep smiling on us!

avatar
Reply

" We would have been better off opening up a prison and letting the inmates run the country."

Or at least my cat. ;-)

avatar
Reply

crghss ~

How does that go? Lie down with dogs - wake up with fleas?

"He only has retirement left"? Hey - lucky him. How

many "regular" people not only lose their retirement

but end up serving time for lying to the Feds?

avatar
Reply

Lying? Who said anything about lying. Is this where people start "lying" to make it seem that something was worse then it really was?

avatar
Reply

It's known as plausible deniability. It means yet again the higher-ups don't take responsibility or get thrown in jail.

avatar
Reply

What I think would be his proper reward is a public beating where everyone turns their back on him like he turned his back on what is right, moral, and the law.

avatar
Reply

So you do infact condone torture?

avatar
Reply

Is ostracism torture?

avatar
Reply

It's called corporal punishment, many people still swear by it and besides, think about the American lives it might save. lol

avatar
Reply

FTA:

...both of whom are known to have undergone waterboarding, which gives the subject the sensation of drowning.

I am so very sick and tired of waterboarding being the

only mention ANYWHERE to our methods of torture!

"WATER-boarding", I mean it just sounds kind of hygienic!

You've got "experts" stating that it's not torture,

it's just psychological - "There's no permanent damage".

If the American public were exposed to more of the actual

methods described, would they get it? Beatings? Freezing -

induced hypothermia, ankles chained to the front legs of

a chair while the spine is extended over the back and

your wrists are chained to the back legs for HOURS?

How about Binyam Mohammed al-Habashi, and the alleged

scalpel cuts to the chest and genitals. Do you think

it might have left scars? Actual evidence of his treatment

will never be seen because the USA cannot afford to let

him out of Guantanamo to substantiate his claims.

avatar
Reply

"the alleged"

Enough said.

avatar
Reply

I hardly think enough has been said. To disprove the "alleged" accusations just produce the "alleged" victim without any physical scars. Fair enough??

avatar
Reply

crghss: '"the alleged" Enough said.'

It's also alleged that they are terrorists.

avatar
Reply

crghss ~

Don't be silly........everything is ALLEGED!

Has our government filed charges to proved the

GUILT? You have to substantiate charges in the justice system - well,you are supposed to. With less blind acceptance and more attention being given to Bush's decisions, it is entirely possible that the justice system might not play ball.

Bush can't afford to let these ALLEGATIONS proceed to a

normal trial where the accused could site the methods used to extract names, plots, confessions - I don't believe that is allowed in a Military Tribunal in their new form.

You're right of center - Yes? Well, I thought you were the guys who liked to say, "If you haven't done anything wrong

then why worry?" If they have not done anything wrong then

why is it imperative that so much be secret,secret,secret???

avatar
Reply

Oh - and don't forget our own Guantanamo guard who was

conned into acting as a prisoner for a training exercise

without notification to the other guards. They beat him

so badly that he will now and forever have the "sensation"

of brain damage! Oh yeah - we're not doing anything

that needs to be secret!

And don't forget Rumsfeld and his attempt to belittle the

stress-positions criticizm, "sometimes I have to stand for 8

hours". Guess what? If he had been beaten like Mr. Dilawar

at Bagram (See "Taxi To The Darkside") it would have been

all he could do. After four days of beatings, our guys

couldn't even force his legs to bend - they were that

swollen.......and then he died. As our own military

examiner said, "pulpified".

Get this stuff out in the open, admit it - and never

ever let us carry out these policies again!

avatar
Reply

'Tapes destroyed over CIA's objections'

What Secret documents did Sandy Berger Destroy for BJ Bill and Swift Boat hillary clinton??

Obama is very Refreshing...

The clinton's are very decptive liars...

avatar
Reply

Sandy doing something wrong does not change the fact that this is wrong. I'm having a hard time understanding what Obama has to do with this either.

avatar
Reply

"What Secret documents did Sandy Berger Destroy for BJ Bill and Swift Boat hillary clinton?"

OK Here we go again. Using a previous act to justify another. What proof if there of anything being destroyed?

Isn't Swift Boat a republican tactic used on Kerry??

"The clinton's are very decptive liars..."

ROFLMAO And the Bush administration isn't?? When are we going to start holding our highest elected officials responsible for their actions??

avatar
Reply

We are not talking about the Clintons here. As bad as they where, they never did as much damage to this country as the current administration has done.

avatar
Reply

I'm surprised that this is still getting any more attention. I was sure this was swept under the carpet, to be replaced by Iran/China/economy/gay marriage/(insert your favorite fate category here).

avatar
Reply

crghss ~

Okay - I knew it was an overstatement when I typed it - I

should have known that you would notice! But, please -

won't testify without immunity? Where does refusing to

testify before Congress fit in your estimation of a person's

character? When do the above-board, straight-forward people

show up to account to us? After they have received plenty

of coverage for their sorry *sses? We, the people of the

United States deserve more than what ever scraps the OVP

and the President finally decide to throw us.

1 2 > »

Add Comment

You must log in first to post a comment. Secure Signin

Not a member? Sign-up today!


Who voted on this story?

View all (110) »

Who sunk this story?

Channels
AnchorsArt & DesignAutos
BooksCareers & JobsCelebrities
Do No EvilDo-It-YourselfFamily
FoodGadgets & TechGay & Lesbian
Health & FitnessHumorLove & Personals
MenMoneyMovies
MusicNewsPets
PoliticsPopular VideosReal Estate
ReligionScienceShopping
SportsTelevisionTravel
VideoVideo GamesWomen